Skip to content

Unhealthy Debate

The health insurance companies have been making lots of noise recently, pretending to support health care reform, but at the same time they have been plotting to double-cross the push for reform. While publicly supporting reform, they have been practicing dirty politics at its worst: lobbying Congress to block the public health insurance option, and filming ads reminiscent of the infamous “Harry and Louise” ads they used to torpedo health care reform during the Clinton administration.

It will be interesting to see if these ads work this time around. They use the same lies they used the last time. For example, ads being put together by Blue Cross Blue Shield show Americans being denied their choice of doctor, or being forced to wait months for appointments. How hypocritical is this? I don’t know what kind of health insurance they are talking about offering — my (very expensive) policy doesn’t give me free choice of doctor, nor free me from waiting for appointments.

Indeed, none of the proposals currently on the table force you to choose a government-run insurance plan. It is the insurance companies who are trying to deny you the choice of a public plan, because it would cut into their obscene profits.

But what is really interesting about this is whether Obama will have the political will to stand up to the insurance companies. During the presidential campaign, Obama said “If those insurance companies and drug companies start trying to run ads with Harry and Louise, I’ll run my own ads as president. I’ll get on television and say ‘Harry and Louise are lying.’”

Well, the insurance companies are about to start running “Harry and Louise” ads. Will Obama keep his promise?

If Obama is serious about changing the way Washington works, of putting the American people above the special interests, this is his big chance.


One Comment

  1. Kevin wrote:

    Hah, even having Blue Cross doesn’t give you no waiting for appointments. That’s determined solely by how busy the doctor you’re trying to see is. I never have problems getting in to see my GP or Urologist in a timely manner. When I’ve needed surgeries they’ve been scheduled quickly, last one I had was scheduled 2 days before it occurred. I literally went in to do the pre-op bloodwork the day after I saw my doctor and had surgery the day after that.

    Meanwhile, my mother, WITH a Blue Cross plan (a good one too) had to wait a YEAR to get in to see a specialist for her arthritis. She wasn’t untreated during that time, her GP treated her as best she could, but she still had to wait 12 whole months.

    Maybe Obama should hunt for people like my Mom there to counter the “Harry and Louise” ads. I doubt there’s any shortage of them.

    Sunday, May 24, 2009 at 5:29 pm | Permalink

2 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Political Irony › Won’t get screwed again? on Sunday, June 7, 2009 at 12:24 pm

    […] also “Unhealthy Debate” and “Reforming Health Insurance Reform“. Close Bookmark and Share This Page […]

  2. Political Irony › Our health depends on it. on Thursday, June 11, 2009 at 11:53 pm

    […] opponents of health care reform claim that if health insurance was provided by the government, then you will not be able to pick your own doctor. Not only is this not true in every plan being proposed in the US, it is not even true in any […]